Posted by: T Y | September 16, 2007

The Outlander Movie: Casting Jamie Fraser

You knew it was coming with The Outlander Movie post: my casting ideas. To be honest, I prefer to see Diana Gabaldon’s Outlander novels adapted into a HBO television series in a one season-one novel format. Screenwriters don’t have to work too hard because each novel comes with a built-in cliffhanger and the integrity of Gabaldon’s vision may be retained because HBO eludes more censors than a blockbuster movie. How else are you going to get away with that Black Jack Randall plotline? In an ideal world, Outlander would be a seven-season HBO series with the dialogue of Deadwood and the historical production value of Rome.

On to casting. HBO executives–I hope you’re taking notes.

The popular YouTube consensus is Gerard Butler as Jamie Fraser. Nothing wrong with that–you can’t deny that the genuine Scotsman is physically blessed by God. It seems like every Outlander fan loves him. So I hate to say it: I can’t see him as Jamie Fraser.

Truth to tell, I think Diana Gabaldon has created an impossible to cast character. Never in my life have I set eyes on a 6′4″ Scotsman with flaming red hair and several hundred years of Viking blood running through his veins. If I ever set eyes on Jamie Fraser in real life, I think I’ll go blind…much like someone will go blind staring at the sun.

With the 300 trailers out on YouTube, I can’t help imaging what Gerard Butler/Jamie Fraser would yell once the Battle of Culloden rolls around: “Madness? This. Is. Scotland!” This image makes me giggle incessantly. Perhaps I speak too soon–I haven’t seen 300, but once I do, I may recant my words and rue the day I ever underestimated Gerard Bulter’s ability to play Jamie Fraser. The picture above of Gerard looking distinctly Jamie Fraser-like doesn’t help me in my decision in discounting him in the coveted role.

If I want to see Outlander filmed while I’m still young and idealistic enough to swoon over this God-like Scotsman, I’d better stick to Gerard Butler who is the closest living resemblance to Jamie Fraser that I’ve seen so far.

But another part of me, the part that takes Diana Gabaldon’s description very literally, would argue that the part should go to some unknown Scottish actor who resembles a young Sean Bean.

I think the young Sean Bean more closely resembles the fair and slender 23-year-old Jamie Fraser of my imagination than Gerard Bulter. The orginal Sean Bean, now in his late-forties, would be perfect to play Jamie Fraser circa Voyager and beyond.

In the picture above, young Sean Bean comes packaged with puffy-white shirt and all. In the picture below, he’s dressed up in full Scots regalia which brings back fond memories of Jamie and Claire’s wedding.

And here is Mr. Bean again with a band of Scottish ruffians, much like the part in the book when Claire stumbles upon Jamie Fraser and his cattle-raiding posse. Although the Scotsmen looked more ferocious and worst-for-wear in my imagination.

Next time on The Outlander Movie…Claire Randall Fraser.

Update:   Casting Jamie Fraser: Part II.   

Possibly related posts: (automatically generated)

Posted in Books, Outlander Series | Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

«
»

Responses

  1. Jamie will be an extremely hard character to cast. Interesting post. I shall follow your logic about casting this movie with interest.

    By: Ms. Place on September 22, 2007
    at 4:17 am

  2. I agree that the books should be made into an HBO mini series. We wouldn’t live to see the final movie if they were made for the big screen, and so much would be left out.
    I kinda like Gerard, but I am open to suggestions for others to play Jamie!

    By: Karen on September 23, 2007
    at 10:07 pm

  3. I think it should be made for the big screen. Its too good a series to be just a mini series. I think Gerard is perfect to play Jamie maybe if he dyed his hair more red. Please just put it to the screen some how because i have read the books and fell in love with them.

    By: sheree on September 30, 2007
    at 8:39 pm

  4. That band of ruffians with Sean Bean is from the Sharpe’s Rifles series but they are Irish ruffians, not Scot. …and I agree, Sean Bean was never better than as Sharpe. He’d be marvelous!

    By: Peggy on October 4, 2007
    at 2:22 pm

  5. Scottish actor Tony Curran would be perfect!

    By: NurseNoir on October 19, 2007
    at 11:24 am

  6. I can’t think of anyone suitable to play Jamie, either, although the young Sean Bean would have been an excellent choice. It’s funny that Gerard Butler is the popular choice (he’s a bit too old, I think), because I’ve always thought he would be the perfect Dougal!

    By: Paula on October 31, 2007
    at 7:19 am

  7. As a genuine Scotsman whose American fiance got him into reading the books, I’d reccomend Kevin McKidd to play Jamie Fraser.
    He’s a genuine Scotsman, red haired, handsome and 6 foot 2 and a half, so almost there.
    He’s also got the very stubborn, brooding and strong personality that characterises Jamie. (Just see him as Bothwell in Gunpowder, treason and plot.)
    See… http://www.lallybroch.com/LOL/guests/kevinm.jpg

    And

    … http://www.bbc.co.uk/northernireland/drama/gunpowder/images/wallpaper_01.jpg

    By: Arlen Donald on October 31, 2007
    at 6:45 pm

  8. Kevin McKidd is also a good choice. I’ve not considered him before because I’m not too sure about his age. I am, however, familiar with his work. I think his performance in “Rome” is spectacular and he made a credible Count Vronsky in the BBC Anna Karenina.

    Thanks everyone for your input! I really enjoy reading about your ideal Jamie Fraser. Keep it coming.

    By: T Y on October 31, 2007
    at 8:52 pm

  9. Please let it be Gerald Butler. I think he would make an outstanding Jamie Frasier. I’ve seen him in 300, Attila and Beowuld and Grendal, he did and excellent job in each and has an amazing softer side too. He definately has that same aire about him. He’s sexy without even trying.
    What about Keira knightley for Claire; she already has an english accent and has played characters from this time period before. I just hope the movie comes out soon. Ive been waiting for what seems like forever.

    By: Michele on November 2, 2007
    at 5:43 pm

  10. My coworker and I have spent months talking about this and we like Donal Logue. Maybe Gabriel Macht as a young Jamie or Ian.

    By: Bree on November 9, 2007
    at 1:34 pm

  11. I think Ned Vaughn has the right look. He doesn’t have the name as some of the choices, but he does have the flaming red hair and blue eyes.

    By: K.T. on November 11, 2007
    at 2:35 am

  12. Jason Isaacs is the undisputed champion to play Black Jack Randall! I just had to get that out, isn’t he perfect??

    By: Erin on November 13, 2007
    at 3:47 pm

  13. I’ve always pictured Liam Neeson as Jaimie. I know he’s not 23, but he’s got the weight and the broodiness and the wry sense of humor. The ohters seem lightweight to me.

    By: Bonnie on November 17, 2007
    at 9:17 pm

  14. Yes, I’ve always pictured Liam Neeson as having the perfect body type to play Jamie Fraser. He’s tall (exactly 6′4″), lean, and we know he can play a credible Scotsman (Rob Roy). In fact, I picture him as a perfect older Jamie Fraser circa ‘Drums of Autumn’ and beyond. I only wished they could have thought of the Outlander movie when Liam Neeson at least looked young enough to play a twentysomething Jamie Fraser…..

    Of course, they can always cast some relative unknown as 23 year old Jamie Fraser, Gerard Bulter as Jamie in his mid-30’s, and Liam Neeson as Jamie 45+…..

    But then, what’s the point of casting someone as sexy as Gerry Butler to play Jamie during his lonely years. He doesn’t get to romance Claire for 20 years!

    By: T Y on November 18, 2007
    at 9:12 am

  15. für Jamie Fraser eine perfecte Person zu finden ist verdammt schwierig! ich finde Gerard Butler ok aber ich finde er ist etwas zu alt für diese Rolle. Wenn es jemand jüngeres wäre fände ich schon besser.

    By: Vanessa on November 24, 2007
    at 11:32 am

  16. I love all the books, and I have for a very long time tried to come up with someone that can play Jamie. I have not come up with a solution… Although I love Gerard Butler, I don’t get the “right” feeling. He is gorgeous and all, but I don’t see him as Jamie. As T Y said, maybe they will find someone unknown to play him… And I also have to agree with Erin.. Jason Isaacs would be great as Jack Randall :)

    By: swefin on November 25, 2007
    at 8:59 am

  17. I truly believe Liam Neeson should play James McKenzie Fraser. They should make a mini series of it. Simply for the fact that a movie at its longest would be 3 hrs. Not enough time to capture every thing in the books.

    By: Theresa on November 29, 2007
    at 3:07 pm

  18. Jamie Fraser is a mythological character, much like Apollo or Hercules. No “Known” actor could play him.

    He should be an “Unknown” actor chosen for his skill/charisma/presence, physical characteristics, and athletic ability. He then “Becomes” the character without comparison.

    Let us not have another “Tom Cruise as LeStat.”

    By: TSpc on November 30, 2007
    at 12:03 pm

  19. TSpc—
    I completely agree that the ideal actor playing Jamie Fraser should be unknown. Celebrity distracts me.

    Let us hope Tom Cruise doesn’t read Outlander and get the bright idea of playing Jamie Fraser. I’ll have nightmares for the rest of my life! They’ll have to cast actors and actresses that are 4 feet tall in order to make Tom Cruise look like a towering scotsman.

    By: T Y on November 30, 2007
    at 4:52 pm

  20. I think that Alex O’Loughlin would make a great Jamie Fraser. As far as the hair it can be dyed.
    I Watched the first episode of his show Moonlight and was hooked. I kept thinking this is the guy who should play Jamie Fraser. There is a couple scenes in Episode 8 with him and a sword. It’s hot! http://www.CBS.COM I also think that Kate Winslet should play Claire. I think she has the spunk and is curvy enough to play Claire. While I like Kiera Knightly I don’t think that she is Claire.
    I think that Jason Isaacs should play Jack Randall, he was wonderful as the bad English officer in The Patriot. And I think that Tommy J Flannigan should play Murtaugh. He was great in Braveheart and I think he would have the right demeanor for it.

    By: storie on December 1, 2007
    at 5:13 am

  21. Storie—
    I could see Kate Winslet as Claire. She did such a good job on her American accent in Titanic that I sometimes forget she’s British. Your right, she’s definitely curvy and sophisticated enough to play Claire; and we know she can carry a movie.

    By: T Y on December 1, 2007
    at 7:44 am

  22. I love this story, Diana Gabaldon is a great writer!
    Thanks to this story(i don’t say book ’cause they are several books for this story) and of course before, I would go and live in Scotland…or in Ireland!
    I think that Jamie Fraser is like each people who had already read the book imagine!
    I hope that you understand what I wanna say..sorry for the other…i’m not English..Thanks God there is Diana Gabaldon§
    Thanks God here is Jamie Fraser and Claire…!!!
    Ciao
    Nazo Turka
    01.12.07
    Now, I’m reading the 3rd book of Outlander!

    By: nazo turka on December 1, 2007
    at 9:47 am

  23. to NAZO TURKA: You go girl! Brilliant that you read stories in languages unfamiliar! You are MY HERO!

    By: TSpc on December 2, 2007
    at 12:14 am

  24. ok so. I just saw beowulf… and whoever that guy is.. apparently a thinner seriously buff version of the guy who doing beowulf’s voice. him but a redhead. unfortunately not a real person. and a gutterish london accent. :(

    By: charlotte on December 4, 2007
    at 1:06 pm

  25. [...] Jamie Fraser: Part II If you recall from my Casting Jamie Fraser post, I’m still on the fence as to who should play the coveted role of Jamie Fraser if [...]

    By: Casting Jamie Fraser: Part II « The Lit Connection on December 12, 2007
    at 6:21 pm

  26. John Corbett, tall, athletic, triangular mouth. Dye his hair and get some contacts, WA LAH.

    By: Kathy on December 15, 2007
    at 1:12 pm

  27. I just saw the new National Treasure and I think Lisa Sheldon would be a great Brianna. She had a small part at the end of the movie, but the moment I saw here, I knew! She is only 5′9″, but I’m sure there is something they could do…

    By: Erin on December 27, 2007
    at 10:57 am

  28. What do you think of Edward Burns to play Jamie Fraser’s role ? i think he would be perfect !

    By: Lucile on December 29, 2007
    at 8:26 am

  29. Sorry, I keep posting in the wrong spots; I will try to control myself. As for Jamie, I am still holding out as to who the perfect actor is, as none of those suggested do it for me. I like the suggestions though; they are all handsome and charismatic men.

    By: Erin on January 3, 2008
    at 12:01 pm

  30. Gerald Butler looks great to me! Just the other day I had thought jason Issacs should play Jack Randall..glad to see others think so as well. Would he then also play Frank??

    By: sharrese on January 7, 2008
    at 8:56 pm

  31. Gerry Butler IS Jamie to me. He has the sharp nose, the stature (he is about 6′ 2″, so thats close enough), an amazing physique, a lovely deep voice, he looks amazing with long hair, he has blue/green eyes, and has high, flat cheekbones…Not to mention his authentic Scottish accent! Plus, he has that perfect mix of good humor, chivalry, courage, sensitivity and roguishness that is essential for Jamie’s character. I also think that Rachel Weiss would make a fabulous Claire because she has that stunning pale skin and dark hair, is very beautiful and very voluptuous. And of course she is British! WHEN ARE THEY GOING TO PUT OUTLANDER TO FILM?? gah.

    By: Anne on January 13, 2008
    at 12:56 am

  32. Heath Legder!

    By: viviana murillo on January 15, 2008
    at 6:58 pm

  33. Hi everyone! You all make great suggestions and while I too, love Gerard Butler, I can’t see him as Jamie(I’m reading the series again for about the 50th time and it doesn’t work for me, visualizing Gerard, as I read) but I do agree with the response that he could be Dougal. Now, here is my suggestion–Michael Fassbender as Jamie–he was in ‘300′ as Stelios. Check him out!

    By: Alex Francis on January 16, 2008
    at 6:59 pm

  34. Chris O’Donnell?

    By: viviana murillo on January 17, 2008
    at 6:32 am

  35. David Conrad, aka Jim Clancy from series Ghost Whisperer would make a great Jamie. He displays all the necessary physical and character attributes – all that’s missing is the red hair & claymore.

    By: marilyn stewart on January 18, 2008
    at 10:21 pm

  36. Any American actor cast as Jamie would be awful, they must stick with a Scot or at least a Brit!

    By: sharrese on January 19, 2008
    at 8:26 pm

  37. Oh my lord – could there possibly be a man who could play the godlike Jamie Fraser….a very hard kilt to fill. If there is I would imagine him to possess the charms and wisdom of Liam Neeson and the raw manly Scottish sexual ooze of Gerard Butler with facial features of Cole Hauser (Tears of the Sun, The Cave). Never has a character quite hit me like Jamie Fraser. I’d recommend my husband however he’s a New Zealander. He possesses many of the same characteristics – 6′4″, blue eyes, lean muscular body, work-hardened features. I like to think of him as my Jamie Fraser :)
    All in all, i’d have to say Gerard Butler but only because he’s Scottish and Cole Hauser is American and only 6′1″

    By: Paulette on January 20, 2008
    at 2:09 am

  38. I think Gerard Butler is great1 He’s Scottish, he’s tall, he can fight, he looks good in a tux, he has beautiful eyes, charm and can adapt to any role – he can handle a sword and can sing!
    For Claire I suggest Kate Beckinsale – she stunning and English. She also looks like Hoang Nguyen’s image from the Graphic novel. I think they would be great for the film
    Sal
    from En

    By: salx452 on January 20, 2008
    at 11:34 am

  39. I think Jamie has to be played by Kevin Mckidd. He actually grew up in the Highlands and has those dark blue eyes! I also think that Kate Beckinsale is perfect as Claire.

    By: SamGriff78 on January 21, 2008
    at 12:45 pm

  40. Honestly-it’ll be hard to cast Jamie if for no other reason than he’s only in his TEENS when the book starts-with Claire quite a bit older. Kevin McKidd, Gerald both LOOK their ages-and I can’t see being able to young them up enough for the first book or two.

    By: Kathryn on February 7, 2008
    at 6:09 pm

  41. I am so sorry folks. I agree with the earlier post. NO high end celebrities will do justice to these amazing stories. We have fallen in love with these characters for all the same reason. They are unlike anything we have read before…
    These characters must be unknowns. Kate Beckinsale, Liam Neeson…I even heard Kiera Knightly! Please tell me your joking.
    Kate is gorgeous, ,yes, but she couldn’t possess the strength of character to play Claire if she tried. Have you watched her movies?
    Liam a fine actor but so far from Jaimie its ridiculous! NOT to mention way too old!
    Kiera…don’t even get me started on her!! screaming her way all through pirates 1. If she pouts much more she will pop her lips off!
    I will agree with Jason Issacs as Jack Randall. He is perfect. Gerard Butler…although hot. Is too old! And he is too short and pigeon toed when he walks. He’s NOT Jaimie…He is close but not It.
    I just pray if these amazing stories should all come to fruition that whoever is involved in their making, they will look at these stories with the same passion we do…

    By: Midnight Angel on February 12, 2008
    at 5:27 pm

  42. I think William Shockley would be a perfect Jamie.

    By: toni on February 13, 2008
    at 7:20 pm

  43. I was watching eastenders while reading voyager when sean slater popped up on screen. It suddenly then came to me that with a good gym regime and accent training he could possibly be a plausible Jamie. A agree though that casting is difficult, jamie is so unique.

    By: Claire on February 14, 2008
    at 5:44 am

  44. Hello!
    It was mere chance that I stumbled over this side and haven`t got enough time to read all the comments…but what about David Wenham as young Jamie? He looks younger than he is…and what he looks like is great…but Sean Bean would be the only one who had been PERFECT, if he was just a little bit younger…Mmpf

    By: Thaly on February 24, 2008
    at 10:49 am

  45. Thaly:
    Funny you should mention David Wenham. See my follow-up post:
    Casting Jamie Fraser: Part II
    http://thelitconnection.wordpress.com/2007/12/12/casting-jamie-fraser-part-ii/

    By: T Y on February 24, 2008
    at 11:27 am

  46. What about Rachel Weiss for Claire?

    By: Sunshine on February 25, 2008
    at 12:49 pm

  47. Hey I have to agree that I don’t think Gerard Butler makes a good Jamie. I just doesn’t quite work. I do however think he would make a great Roger MacKenzie in the later books as that is how I imagine Roger to look. Sean Bean is just about there for Jamie though and with a bit more red in his hair I think he could do it.

    By: shona on March 7, 2008
    at 5:21 pm

  48. Jamie should have fiery hair and look young.

    By: katie on March 8, 2008
    at 11:58 pm

  49. What about Eric Stoltz? He’s “only” 6 ft., but has portrayed Scottish actors with aplomb, and he was such a hunk in “Rob Roy.” And he looks younger than he is.

    By: Libby on March 10, 2008
    at 9:19 pm

  50. Henry Cavill from the Tudors is the perfect Jamie… 6′1, blue eyes – dye is hair auburn and he’s the one!

    By: amber lu on March 11, 2008
    at 6:29 pm

  51. Sheamus O’Shaunessy. A red haired wrestler. 6′6″ with naturally red hair. Plus most wrestlers must do some acting in their shows.

    By: Buffy on March 22, 2008
    at 10:25 pm

  52. Hey, Matthew McFayden! Dye his hair red and he’d be purrfect.

    By: chartroose on March 25, 2008
    at 6:18 pm

  53. Jamie should be an unknown. actor

    By: hanna on March 28, 2008
    at 8:04 am

  54. I saw a picture of Henry Cavill and my GOD he is Jamie. All he needs is red hair…he’s beautiful and the perfect age!

    By: Cathy on March 31, 2008
    at 2:01 pm

  55. Ah canna believe it!! Pit that bonnie loon Gerry Butler as Jamie, naebidy can manage tae access the real essence o’ a Scotsman wie the dilema o’ gan tae battle or love! He has the look through and through, jist nae the reed hair… that is easily remedied!!
    Gie me Gerry oni day, he is gorgeous and and Scots tae boot, wie the look o’ a deep and enthralling man, stubborn and yet oh so sexy. Nithin’ like it lassies, Scots men like him are just afa bonnie.

    By: Jeanette on April 4, 2008
    at 1:56 pm

  56. NO!!! It has to be Gerry!! as a scotslass awa fae hame, I have to say to you, if you aren’t scots then you don’t know the real scots in Jamie, Gerry captures him beautifully!!

    You have to be true to his character, and he is a lovely specimen of a scotsman with a fine acting career and the REAL DEAL accent, which is really hard to duplicate.

    By: Jeanette on April 4, 2008
    at 1:59 pm

  57. I have a suggestion,..what about karl Urban he played Eomer on LOTR? this is a link to a rather spectacular photo of him;
    http://www.autographdealer.com/images/KarlURban443.jpg

    By: Eleanor on April 17, 2008
    at 7:33 am

  58. Henry Cavill…not a Jamie but how about Black Jack Randal? :
    http://us.movies1.yimg.com/movies.yahoo.com/images/hv/photo/movie_pix/touchstone_pictures/the_count_of_monte_cristo/henry_cavill/count.jpg

    By: Eleanor on April 17, 2008
    at 7:35 am

  59. Scratch that….Lord John for Henry Cavill. LOL..sorry change of heart.

    By: Eleanor on April 17, 2008
    at 7:37 am

  60. Viggo Mortenson! He’s Brooding and also sensitive, when you see him as Aragorn in LOTR he’s ferocious and strong, a leader, thats the Jamie I imagine.
    He has those Viking Jamiesque features, long straight nose,strong chin( his father is Danish! so he should have viking features!) has beautiful eyes and can carry off the red hair I reckon.
    I think Catherine Zeta Jones or Rachel Weiss could easily be Claire, they both have the ability to look much younger, and then progress to the older ages portrayed in the books.

    By: Jax on April 25, 2008
    at 10:14 pm

  61. Oh My.. and Hugh Dancy would make a marvelous young Lord John Grey!I am sure they could age him sufficiently to continue playing John as the stories progess. Jim Caveizel for Roger Mac perhaps?God knows where they would find a 6ft+ actress with the looks and presence to play Bree though! Bearing in mind that she would have to resemble whoever they choose to play Jamie if they want to stay true to the books.
    As would whoever they find to play William, Jamie’s illegitimate son. Its a hard Job, but as much as I think it would be great to have total unknowns, that would prob make it easier, the magnitude of these movies would dictate the need for at least a couple or so big names in the starring rolls.

    By: Jax on April 26, 2008
    at 8:15 pm

  62. Oh and I was just looking at some earlier posts, and I thought of Kate Winslett once for claire, but as much as I love her acting..she still seems too young for me. I think for me Rachel Weiss is usually who I envisage as her,and kate Beckinsale? noooh..too wishywashy! Keira Knightly!!? NO WAY, not as claire..WAY too tall and skinny as well. Needs a womanly woman to be claire for sure.. I PRAY they ask Rachel.
    Actually I think Alicia Witt could be Bree, but Penny Drake would fit the bill better still.

    By: Jax on April 27, 2008
    at 7:39 am

  63. Por favor mirad esta foto… de James Franco, si tuviera ojos azules y un reflejo más cobrizo… ¿No tiene la fortaleza de Jamie? pero asu vez su ingenuidad y melancolía de un pasado triste y doloroso.. que decís? Además da con su edad…
    Ver…

    http://images.allmoviephoto.com/2006_Tristan_and_Isolde/2006_tristan_and_isolde_003.jpg

    http://images.starpulse.com/pictures/2007/04/24/previews/James%20Franco-ASG-004963.jpg

    http://spf.fotologs.net/photo/63/21/44/jhoanna_g/1187841922_f.jpg

    http://www.iwatchstuff.com/2008/02/13/pineapple-express-trailer.jpg

    By: María Jo. on May 12, 2008
    at 2:41 pm

  64. I would have to say that if Gerard Butler dyed his hair red with auburn and blond highlights he’d be the best candidate for Jamie Fraser. I’ve seen his acting and I think he would pull off the ‘very protective’ strong, chivalrous, larger than life character of Jamie quite well. This Sean Bean fellow…no, out of all of Gabaldon’s descriptions of her character Jamie Fraser, he is the exact opposite. Maybe a good role for Fergus or even the elder Ian Murray, but he is by far too slender and ‘weak’ looking to be Jamie. If my husband were an actor…he’d be the most perfect candidate…being 6′4 with green eyes and Scottish ancestry..however, I don’t see him ever being in the film business. ;)

    By: Victoria on May 28, 2008
    at 5:58 pm

  65. I have recently seen the movie Pathfinder performing Karl Urban (Eomer-Lord of the Rings) as, guess what, a Viking boy left behind after an incursion in America 500 some years before Christopher Columbus. He is raised by native americans and later on, when he’s grown up he must fight a second Viking invasion to defend the tribe that cared for him. Seeing Urban there immediately brought to me memories of Jamie Fraser, altough he does not have blue eyes, he is very tall and ellegant, and’s got a boyish face that can be as young or as old as you want to picture.

    By: Emmanuela Grasso on June 11, 2008
    at 5:21 am

  66. Even though Gerard Butler is amazing in 300, I just don’t think he would do Jamie justice. My vote is for Ewan McGregor. He’s a Scottish, blue-eyed beauty who would look absolutely dashing in Highland regalia, and there’s no doubt he could pull off both Jamie’s tender and fierce side.

    p.s. I think it’s a great idea to make the Outlander books into an HBO series!

    By: Carolyn on June 13, 2008
    at 1:24 pm

  67. Athough beautiful (I agree) Ewan McGregor is too small.

    By: emmagz1971 on June 17, 2008
    at 6:34 am

  68. I have found someone who looks like Jamie:
    The german soccer player Christoph Metzelder!

    Only the haircolour is not the right one…

    By: Leonie on June 21, 2008
    at 8:32 am

  69. How about the guy from Brothers and Sisters.. he’d have to bulk up a little but thats who has always come to my mind since I started reading the books.

    Dave Annable is his name.

    By: Tracy on June 28, 2008
    at 3:04 am

  70. OH MY GOODNESS!! I am very glad that I won’t have the job of casting a movie like this :) Because it looks like some fan is going to be mad at you – no matter WHO you choose :)

    I used to think Gerard Butler was a good choice and maybe he still is one of the better choices out there. Matthew McFayden too maybe? He’s got MY vote anyway – Sorry – but a big NO to Sean Bean enthusiasts out there and Ewan McGreggor? PUH-leaze! I don’t see him as Jamie…EVER…and maybe that’s the problem….

    It’s a book character and since the start we have all envisioned Jamie Fraser differently. Ms Gabaldon did such a FANTASTIC job of describing “Himself”. I don’t think we’ll ever get the perfect Jamie. My only worry is that they will choose someone and that person’s features will be “super-imposed” on MY personal image of Jamie and thus forever spoil it for me.

    So to the Casting director – Good luck and know that if you botch this up – You’re in trouble !!! :) :)

    By: Toinetté on July 7, 2008
    at 4:35 am

  71. I vote for Kevin McKidd as Jamie.

    By: Daphne on July 10, 2008
    at 4:49 pm

  72. I agree a million percent in Jason Patrick as Black Jack. I can’t imagine any other Englishman who plays as delicious an evil character as Jason – for Claire, lots of nominations for winsome, delicate looking women (with the exception of a suggestion for Kate Winslet – who if you look at her, has a nicely curvy sort of figure but looks sturdy enough to be able to tug and tote and survive 18th Century Scotland. (Hideous Kinky).

    Kevin McKidd blew me away when I caught glimpse of him in Made of Honor – I immediately thought of Jamie – he’s young enough to pull off the 23 year old Jamie but mature enough to get through the agining process believably. He’s got the right build as well. Ewan is great looking but he’d not be hardy enough for Jamie’s build.

    By: Robin Luther on July 13, 2008
    at 3:04 pm

  73. I agree with Anne. Gerard Butler IS and will always be Jamie. (Unless you go for my husband who is naturally red, same features, just not as buff) I have seen some doctored photos of Gerard with red hair and he can definately pull it off. I was hesitant at first, but once I saw the picture I was sold!
    As far as Claire goes, yes! Rachel Weisz! She has it all, everything Claire has. Plus, she has a little of an attitude as well as Claire.
    The HBO series is an extremely perfect idea! Just look at how well the Tudors is doing, not to mention has similar qualities, action, drama, sex. No time travel though. I think it would bring a larger fan base if it were a series compared to a full screen movie. Plus, we don’t have all our lives to wait for seven or so books to be turned into movies. But I do know that Diana needs to hustle it to get the new book done.

    By: Lisa on July 17, 2008
    at 4:28 pm

  74. Darren Boyd- I can’t find any good pics of him online, he used to be in the British show Smack the Pony… He looks to me like a Jamie Fraser- and he’s definitely got the build- he’s 6′4″ and not lanky. Verra good lookin’…*grins* I think he’s in his early thirties, so if it was cast relatively soon, he could possibly still fit the bill…. oh but of course a young Sean Bean would also be dreamy :D

    By: Annelies on July 21, 2008
    at 5:16 am

  75. I stand by my choice: John Rhys Meyers. Tall, catlike, knife-edged nose, he’s got the eyes, and I’m damn well sure he could have the accent down quick. Plus, he looks YOUNG. People always see Jamie in his forties… but we meet him when he’s 23, and Claire when she’s 27. I haven’t a clue who’d play Claire… but the more I think about Rhys Meyers, the more he becomes Jamie.

    By: Heather on July 21, 2008
    at 5:50 pm

  76. I DISAGREE

    “Any American actor cast as Jamie would be awful, they must stick with a Scot or at least a Brit!”

    I have been pouring over all the suggestions for casting Jamie Frasier and emphatically disagree with this statement. My pick for Jamie would be Josh Holloway. He plays the charming rogue on ABC’s Lost. He even has the slanted blue eyes that melt your insides. Now that I think of it his “love interest”, on the show, is a curly haired brunette named Kate played by Evangeline Lilly. Although she is not tall like Clair, she would do and the chemistry between the two of them on the show is as hot as a nuclear meltdown.

    By: Christine on July 22, 2008
    at 5:51 pm

  77. I started reading the Outlander series 3 years ago and honestly, Gerard Butler was the “Jamie” in my head the entire time. Is he older than 23, yes. But let’s face it, if they ever do a movie or miniseries, there are sure to be some changes from the book. Rarely do they adhere to the original 100%. It honestly won’t bother me one iota if Jamie is in his early 30s rather than his 20s. Who cares?! They can absolutely get around the age thing with the right adjustment of time. The trick is getting the right Scotsman to play the role. And I’m sorry ladies, but in my mind Mr. Butler is THE MAN! For fun, just watch some of his interviews on Leno…smart, charming, funny, and oh so sexy. Some red in that hair and we’re there. (Aren’t opinions great?!)

    By: Lyn on July 28, 2008
    at 8:10 am

  78. Okay, I’m going to throw this out there and hunker down for the onslaught. Brendan James Fraser IS a Fraser, speaks French fluently “Je suis prest!”, 6 foot 3 inches, you should see some of the pics on the web of him mostly naked posing as Neptune or some mythological creature, long hair entwined with seaweed. At least he could correct people on how to say the surname properly. I know we all see him as the goof in George of the Jungle et al but remember Michael Keaton played Beetlejuice before he did intense Batman…we know he can do action movies, let’s see if he can do a Scottish accent (his acting chops were cut in London actually). Maybe it’s time to let Brendan grow up. He does have a nice stubborn-male mojo thing going…

    By: Marcie on August 1, 2008
    at 7:00 pm

  79. Robert Kazinsky aka Sean Slater from Easternders is the only man i can think of that would do Jamie Fraser Justice

    By: Alexandra on August 3, 2008
    at 10:53 am

  80. Going back to posting of last 2007, I agree about Liam Neeson being my vision of Jamie when I read the books.

    By: Diane James on August 18, 2008
    at 12:39 pm

  81. I once did see a 6′4″ (or taller) Scotsman with flaming red hair, in full kilt, no less. I was 9 years old in 1981, and this fellow was on walkabout in Australia, God knows why. He was shopping in the Queen Street Mall in Brisbane . . .even at age nine I was in awe, and my own Dad is no slouch at 6′2″. But this guy was amazing . . . 27 years later I am still drooling.

    By: Jen on August 18, 2008
    at 6:01 pm

  82. I’ve just started listening to the Outlander series on recorded books. Well, first book, I’ll be getting Dragonfly in Amber. I just love Jamie. He’s handsome and one hell of a lover.

    Anyway, I was hoping they would hopefully do a series of movies based on the books.

    As far as an actor to play him. Well, I don’t really know any scottish actors who would even play the part. I’m thinkin they should cast an unknown for it and if they choose someone for the vision/image I’m thinkin Jamie should be and if their choice is correct in my eyes, I’ll be a puddle on the floor. I only wish I were in Claire’s shoes.

    By: Darlene on August 22, 2008
    at 7:48 pm

  83. I think that Dean McDermott (AKA Tori Spelling’s husband) would make a fine Jamie…he’s big, Scottish, and he’s got that “rough around the edges” look about him…can’t think of anyone else that would do….can you?

    By: Lan on August 24, 2008
    at 6:36 am

  84. Alan Tudyk would play an amazing amazing Jamie in my opinion… his eyes and his hair, and he has a heart of strength and love. His smile completes every gawky smile Jamie has made in Outlander. If i were to cast anyone for jamie, it would be Alan Tudyk. Jamie fools around alot too, this guy has humor.

    http://wireimage.com/SearchResults.aspx?igi=284888&s=Alan%20Tudyk&sfld=C&vwmd=e

    By: Kayla on August 25, 2008
    at 9:31 am

  85. All I have to say is Alexander Skarsgard!
    He would be perfect. Talented but relatively unknown in North America.
    Makes you feel safe and dangerous all at the same time!
    Check out Generation kill if you have any doubts.

    By: Barbara on August 26, 2008
    at 1:30 pm

  86. Sorry people – Ewan McGregor, as gorgeous as he is, and I love him to bits, is too softly spoken to play Jamie. Gerard Butler is most definitely the man for the role – he is beautiful and he has a huge presence about him.

    By: Leona on August 28, 2008
    at 12:27 am

  87. I have read all the Outlander books and Gerard Butler is Jamie old or not. Please don’t blow this its what we all need is a great story with humor and drama,It has been for ever since I have seen a great movie. They don’t make them any more.We got lost some place in all the new crap that their making now.Don’t blow this.

    By: mary jane on August 31, 2008
    at 5:44 am

  88. I was browsing and found this image…I’m only 16 but I am totally engrossed with the series! Also because one of the characters shares my name…I do hope they make this wonderful series into a movie and Sean does make a wonderful Jamie…

    By: Lagohaire Stechmann on September 7, 2008
    at 10:36 pm

  89. Without a doubt, Gerard Butler is Jamie Fraser! He’s convincing as a warrior and a protector. Gerard would also be convincing as a sexy, tender lover. He is a true Scot, this role needs a true Scot. I think Gerard could also nail Jamie Fraser’s sense of humor! If your desperate for a Claire…you might want to consider ME! I don’t have an English Accent but hey, I am a quick learner.

    By: Louise on September 9, 2008
    at 5:09 pm

  90. I think That If they got around to making Voyager, Drums of Autum, The Fiery Cross Gerrad Ullie (hannible Rising) Should play Fergus (older) and James Mc Avoy For Young Ian (In America After he comes back from the Mohawk)

    By: Tlcasselman on September 13, 2008
    at 3:02 pm

  91. Claire: Julia Ormond or Alex Kingston (with Darker Hair)

    By: Tlcasselman on September 13, 2008
    at 3:07 pm

  92. Hey, what about Keri Russel for Claire and Oliver Coleman for Jamie? I love Kevin Mc Kidd and Jery Butler, but they are way too old, I’m afraid.

    By: zarptiza on September 18, 2008
    at 9:18 am

  93. Kayla…. Alan Tudyk is an EXCELLENT suggestion as well! I really loved him in Firefly, as well as A Knight’s Tale. I could most certainly see him as Jamie.

    I do love Gerard Butler…. VERY MUCH SO! But somehow just cannot picture him as Jamie. He has an enormous presence & I believe more than enough ability to play the role I’m sure, but I’m not sure they can pull off making him look like a 6′4″ redheaded Scotsman….Scot or not. LOL. But then, I can’t think of many Scottish men who ARE 6′4″. :-) The tough part for me is going to be if they cast someone who does NOT have some size to him it will be hard for me to buy it. Jamie will always tower over the other men in my mind’s eye. LOL!

    As for Kevin McKidd & age, I realize that we do meet Jamie in Outlander when he’s 23…but the thing to keep in mind is that 300 years ago someone in their 20’s would not have looked like we do today. People aged a lot more quickly & I’m sure had a much more rugged demeanor to them. Just a thought. Not to mention that hollywood makeup can do a lot in that department….just take a gander at how young they made Patrick Dempsey look for his college age scens in Made of Honor.

    But then I guess when I’ve read the books I’ve never once pictured Jamie as a really young man…he’s always had more of a late 30’s – 40’s appearance in my mind’s eye. I’m sure it’s different for everyone, as is evidenced here.

    As for Claire… I cannot see Kristin Scott Thomas in the role, I just can’t. I CAN, however, see Kate Winslet pulling it off. I can also see Rhona Mitra (Doomsday) playing Claire.

    For years I’ve seen Alicia Witt in my mind’s eye as Brianna….. to me, she is the perfect Brianna.

    I just hope it all comes together & we actually get to see all our beloved characters come to life….and that we aren’t all disappointed.

    By: Hootie Patootie on September 23, 2008
    at 7:47 am

  94. I think the British actor Rupert Penry-Jones is a good choice for Jamie.

    Although he doesn’t have the cat like eyes described in the book, his coloring is right and he’s 6′2 or 6′3.

    I imagine Jamie as being very broad shouldered but I still think RPJ could pull it off.

    By: susan on September 23, 2008
    at 11:31 am

  95. If anyone watched Grey’s Anatomy last night, they would have met Jamie Fraser in the flesh…. KEVIN MCKIDD IS JAMIE FRASER. No doubt in my mind. For years I was convinced that only Gerard Butler could do it, but seeing Kevin last night on Grey’s made me change my mind.

    By: Jo-Anne on September 26, 2008
    at 4:08 am

  96. Just watched the opener of Grey’s Anatomy and saw the first actor I’d buy as Jamie – Kevin McKidd a/k/a Dr. McSquirmy.

    By: cj on September 26, 2008
    at 7:14 am

  97. GENTE eu preciso saber, vai ter filme ou não sobre a série Outlander ou já tem??? Eu preciso assistir eu amo aquele livro……..

    By: Letícia Ribeiro on September 26, 2008
    at 3:07 pm

  98. Peter Sarsgaard? find the picture of him with the beard
    Though I thought David Wenham was absolutely inspired as well. Actually looking at him made me go grab a copy of Outlander.

    Gerard Butler is TOO OLD! Gorgeous but too old. Much better as Dougal.

    By: Catie on September 28, 2008
    at 8:13 am

  99. stephon bonnet for sure

    By: Donna on October 3, 2008
    at 7:22 pm

  100. None of the actors fit to the charakters in the book, because everyone has an individual image of them. Therefore it doesn’t bother me if they look different than in the book. The main thing is that they should be able act out the charakters in the book.

    By: Rumeysa on October 4, 2008
    at 11:21 am

  101. I don’t watch Eastenders so I am not aware of this actor’s character but I really think that Robert Kazinsky looks like a young Jamie.
    Look him up on http://www.robertkazinsky.org

    By: Hollaby on October 4, 2008
    at 1:21 pm

  102. Two words-Max Martini

    By: Susan on October 7, 2008
    at 10:59 am

  103. I’ve read all the books in this series quite a number of times and my first choice was Gerard Butler for the part of Jamie only because of his lovely accent but the problem with him is he is nothing like Jamie in appearence so what would be the point! … but after watching a film recently with the actor Kevin McKidd… I just cant seem to get his image out of my head … he is big as I have imagined Jamie to be.. he is a definate red head … the loveliest blue eyes like Jamie has and the face is definately viking looking!… and on top of all these qualities HE IS SCOTTISH and you wouldnt have to worry about him not fitting into the role… he is not as well known as some actors but Jesus H Roosevelt he is definately our Jamie… just have a look at him in the mini series of Rome… there is one photo on the net here under images for Kevin McKidd and the face just blew me away!…
    I’m for Kevin McKidd he has my definate vote as Jamie!

    By: Ness on October 15, 2008
    at 3:48 am

  104. And on top of all this information Kevin McKidd is left handed like Jamie Fraser… now how could you possibly go with someone else!

    By: Ness on October 15, 2008
    at 3:59 am

  105. nobody will be the perfect Jamie we all have our own dream. I think David Wehnam is the one.
    Gerard Bulter is yummy too but I dont think he has the look of innocent needed. Blessings

    By: Rosemary on October 15, 2008
    at 5:57 pm

  106. Sorry Rosemary but David Wehnam looks nothing like the discription of Jamie in the books!

    By: Ness on October 18, 2008
    at 7:51 pm

  107. I think Sean Bean is a great jamie. i love ewan McGregor though..he is who I picture when i’m reading the books. i didn’t think kevin McKidd would be good until I saw him as a General on Grey’s Anatomy. i can know totally see him as the older Jamie.

    By: Breezy on October 23, 2008
    at 6:34 pm

  108. Diana Gaboldon said the closest version of jamie she could find is Gabriel Aubrey….go look him up. i can see Jamie very much…wonder if he can act?
    i think rachel Weiz could play claire

    By: Breezy on October 23, 2008
    at 7:15 pm

  109. hi, i’ve got photos of my new emo hair
    on http://xrl.us/ouog6

    By: emoboy on October 24, 2008
    at 1:10 pm

  110. I think Sean Bean is so hot and sexy looking and i love watching him on tv.

    By: Deanna on October 26, 2008
    at 9:32 am

  111. Kevin. McKid. is. Jamie. Hands. Down.

    By: Katie McAllister on November 4, 2008
    at 12:11 pm

  112. If my husband was an actor he is the perfect Jamie. He is 6′5″, redhead, and good looking man with a look of his own. His parents call him Jamie so I have enjoyed the book by just looking at my husband. Even his characteristics are a lot like Jamie’s. So while many people dream of their Jamie, I am lucky enough to look up and see my wonderful husband who I call Mac.

    By: Angela McPherson on November 8, 2008
    at 8:02 am

  113. I think Gabriel Aubrey should be Jamie. He has the cat eyes, the nose and the chin. I think he would be good.

    By: Christina on November 10, 2008
    at 5:00 pm

  114. And maybe Hayden Christensen as the young Ian

    By: Christina on November 10, 2008
    at 5:34 pm

  115. The undoubtedly best version of Jamie Fraser (young) that I have found is Jason Lewis—-I urge every one to take a gander and remember the hair can be dyed!! Lets remember he is not supposed to be puny……and Sean Bean are you serious????????

    By: yeken on November 11, 2008
    at 10:56 am

  116. and kudos to the Josh Holloway suggestion—–verra nice!

    By: yeken on November 11, 2008
    at 11:09 am

  117. i think the book shouldn’t even have a movie to begin with. jamie fraser, as we all know (FOR ALL THOSE WHO HAVE READ THE FANTASTIC OUTLANDER SERIES) is our man of our dreams. we imagine him. creating him the way we want him to look like. having a movie with someone acting him out will just destroy our so called “mcdreamy”

    2nd
    as we all know and as we all have seen, making a movie out of a book will only destroy the story due to the fact that movies have to be 1 hour and a half long only. making an 800- page book fit into that span of time will not only compromise the story but also will recreate what we’ve imagined in our own minds.

    books are for reading and imagining. not for making movies out of it.

    By: FLENZ on November 12, 2008
    at 5:26 am

  118. Diana Gabaldon said it best herself, that while Gerald Butler is a very fine looking Scotsman, he will have a difficult time pulling off a 22 year old virgin. Gerald Butler is too old people. Is he hot still? Absolutly! But even Hollywood can’t bring him down to 22. Sorry to disappoint

    By: Elizabeth Lees on November 13, 2008
    at 10:27 am

  119. Jamie is uncastable, But Josh Holloway and Gabriel Aubrey came close. (Can the latter act, though?)

    How about Joe Anderson of Across the Universe fame? I think he can may be, possibly, some how get Jamie right.

    By: Sv on November 15, 2008
    at 8:00 pm

  120. Josh Holloway is my Jamie. A little hair dye and a good accent coach. He’s perfect!

    By: Lally on November 19, 2008
    at 7:37 pm

  121. Funny, just playing around and I came across this model… hmmm, has possiblities, don’t you think?

    http://www.unique.dk/eng/Direct/Male/Aaron-B

    By: debra on November 21, 2008
    at 10:11 pm

  122. KEVIN MCKIDD. He not only looks like Jamie, he has the all around essence of James Fraser.

    Who are they thinking for Roger? Maybe David Wenham could be Roger? I really like him as well.

    Josh Holloway is almost too pretty to be Jamie. He’s just so perfectly good looking.

    By: Lee on November 23, 2008
    at 8:13 pm

  123. The australion actor Alex O’Loughlin would be my choise. Great actor, good looks and a Scottish descendant. Combines sensitvity, charisma and strength.

    By: Gerda on November 29, 2008
    at 5:34 am

  124. Make him the mature Jamie in the movie, but if anyone other than Gerard Butler is cast in the role, I won’t watch it. Any one else would be a travisity. Gerry IS Jamie Fraser. If this preproduction stuff goes on until 2020, then just don’t make the movie at all. Leave us with our image of Jamie/Gerry. Do you realize how many people have read these books with only Gerard Butler in mind? (Maybe by the time the film is made, Gerry will have a son who looks just like him and Gerard Jr. could take the role! The only acceptable alternative)

    By: rose on November 30, 2008
    at 9:05 pm

  125. How about Simon Woods? He’s young, good-looking…I hated the recent Pride and Prejudice and had forgotten all about him until I watched the BBC adaptation of Cranford. The only downside I could see is that he is 5′11. I’d rather see a slightly shorter actor play Jamie than someone too old or too “gritty” for the part.

    http://thecia.com.au/reviews/p/images/pride-and-prejudice-9.jpg

    http://farm1.static.flickr.com/120/279215188_482b8138a1.jpg?v=0

    By: Meg on December 2, 2008
    at 5:01 pm

  126. I think David Garrett looks exactly like Jamie Fraser!
    The long nose, the eyebrows…
    Only the eyes and the hair has another colour.

    http://www.odeon-concerte.de/Presse/Pressefotos/Garrett_David%201.jpg

    Does he looks like Jamie?!

    By: Sonea on December 3, 2008
    at 4:14 am

  127. Dear TY,

    I respectfully disagree with your choice for Jaime. However, I have a different role in mind for Mr. Sean Bean. The handsome, scary pirate that comes into play much late in the books. I bet he would love to sink his teeth into THAT role.

    By: Mary on December 4, 2008
    at 7:43 pm

  128. Sonea,

    David Garrett is *very* good looking, and would make a good Jamie, but his coloring is a little off. I don’t think he has the luminous skin of a red head, and his eyes are dark. I’d have to see him after makeup, with his hair dyed and contacts in to say…

    I like Gabriel Aubrey, as well…

    By: Meg on December 5, 2008
    at 4:19 pm

  129. Gabriel Aubrey would be perfect. He’s gone the long straight nose and cat-like eyes. He’s 6′2″ and ridiculously attractive. It would be a wonderful thing if he could act.

    My other suggestion is Philip Winchester. He’s 6′1″. If he could pull off the accent, I think he could meet the challenge of being Jamie Fraser.

    http://cache.daylife.com/imageserve/0aJme449wdb9b/610x.jpg

    http://img2.timeinc.net/ew/dynamic/imgs/080822/freshfaces/philip-winchester-crusoe_l.jpg

    I love Gerald Butler, but I think he’s just too old. Remember that Jamie starts off as a 22 year old virgin. I really don’t think he can pull that off.

    By: Jos on December 7, 2008
    at 5:03 am

  130. My vote would be for Kevin McKidd – all the way. He a Highland Scot, has the looks (red hair, height, great build), and is VERY talented.

    Gerald Butler is too old. David Garrett doesn’t have the coloring, although perhaps he would make a good Dougal? Simon Woods is too young looking – not rough around the edges enough – but once again, would be good in another role.

    By: Tara on January 6, 2009
    at 8:32 am

  131. I’m new at the books and LOVE THEM (why didn’t someone tell me about these years ago???) and I feel like it should be a mini-series too. The audible book that started me on it was 32 hours long! Probably a new young actor should play Jamie, or someone who can pass for a younger version of Sean or Gerard for the first movie. I like the way they both look, but they don’t look like 22 year old virgins! No sir-ee!

    By: Cyndy on January 9, 2009
    at 7:20 pm

  132. I don´t think that Gerry is too old, look at Atilla, there he looks very young – i think! I would like to see Gerry as Jamie

    By: Kristina on January 13, 2009
    at 10:09 am

  133. I only have ideas for Jamie and Claire and those are Kevin McKidd and Alex Kingston. Of course Kevin would need more red in that hair, but he is a Scot and just has the look in his face…I think.

    By: busymama on January 16, 2009
    at 2:11 pm

  134. Okay…I just thought of someone for Brianna. Laura Prepon…Donna Pinciotti…from That 70’s Show. She’s young enough and has that look. I can’t think of anyone else for the other characters though. I have someone pictured for Roger and Stephen, but can’t think of their names right now.

    By: busymama on January 16, 2009
    at 7:27 pm

  135. Sorry, but I missed a few suggestions earlier while I was reading through. I really didn’t mean to post 3 times…Alicia Witt would be good as Brianna too. And I agree, Sean Bean would be a wonderful Stephen Bonnett…long, greasy hair and dirty him up a little…bingo!

    By: busymama on January 16, 2009
    at 8:52 pm

  136. Gerry is definately to old, he has changed since Attila and Phantom. You can see that he is older than 23, even if you put tons of Make up on. You can see that in PS I love you were he plays a 25 year old one at one point and you can see very well that he is oldr than this.
    Gerry is perfect for the Edinburgh/America time.

    For the young Jamie I wuld suggest Robert Pattinson. He quite popular now due to Twilight.
    hes got the age, quite the looks and with some workout he could pull off Jamie very well, hes an amazing ad talented actor.

    By: Lisa on January 17, 2009
    at 6:30 am

  137. Vincent Cassel!

    By: JV on January 20, 2009
    at 1:05 pm

  138. I think it would be very wise to cast an unknown, genuine Scottish man, for Jamie. Gerard Butler would be great – for a 40 yr old Jamie!! Jamie is so young at the beginining, they have to get someone who looks young, not some ruggedly handsome 40ish actor. All the men people suggest are just too old! Can’t they just walk around Scotland and find a man to do this part, I mean, the true Scottish accent has to be the hardest part. I honestly haven’t been able to come up with someone I truly see as Jamie, except possibly David Wenham and Karl Urban, both of the Lord of The Rings movies, but they are a little old too! Ahhhh!!

    By: A.C. Mize on January 24, 2009
    at 6:07 pm

  139. It’s Gerry or nobody. Don’t even try making it without him. We’ll just keep the books and forget a movie.

    By: rose on January 26, 2009
    at 11:06 pm

  140. I just saw Evangeline Lilly from Lost this morning and I think we have a Claire. It’s the eyes! She has the energy for Claire and she’s gorgeous.
    As for Jamie someone better get into the Highlands and start combing the countryside. This man has to be big at least 6′5″. Big men have a softness to them and can be fierce when need be, like Jamie. I know it’s acting but still. But we need a Warrior!!!

    By: jackie on January 27, 2009
    at 9:10 am

  141. My vote goes for Clive Owen….. he may be a bit too old and a brunette, but god is he hot!

    By: Lupe on January 28, 2009
    at 9:08 pm

  142. Simon Baker – OK he’s an Australian actor, but he’s got the hair, the height, the eyes and hes drop dead gorgeous grin. There is also something mysterious about the way he carries himself and something hes always keeping to himself. You can’t read his face – just like our Jamie

    By: Kirrily on February 1, 2009
    at 7:41 pm

  143. The popular votes for Jamie seem to be:
    Gerard Butler, Sean Bean, David Wenham, Kevin McKidd, Josh Holloway etc. But I don’t think of them look AT ALL like Jaime is described. I know it is a hard thing to cast someone like Jaime though.
    First, his physical appearance is so strikingly unique! He is VERY tall, slender, pale, red hair (but its like a golden red if you will recall!) blue cat-like eyes, ears that stick out, full wide lips, battered and scarred and clean-shaven people!
    Then there’s his personality… he’s got a sense of humour and is a charming ladies man but he’s also very stubborn with a STRONG presence. You have to believe that he is a warrior. For this reason I can see why most people have suggested Gerard Butler. He has definitely got Jamie’s personality. I wonder if he was the inspiration??
    I agree that Gabriel Aubrey looks most like Jamie but he’s model not an actor. Too bad.
    I would have to support the suggestions of Max Martini, Alexander Skarsgard (although if he’s Swedish he couldn’t possibly do a Scottish accent…) or Henry Cavill. These guys are good looking and have blonde hair and pale skin, so you could easily do red highlights.
    At any rate… I found a drawing of Jamie on Diana Gabaldon’s website and it is exactly what I had pictured of him. Don’t know if its still there (it was pictured above an excerpt from the story).

    Although I would love to see Jamie look like what we all imagined, I think a true Outlander fan would be more concerned if he could act or not.
    For that reason I think we need a serious no-name actor. Sometimes these turn out to be the best!

    Here is a sketch of Claire that I found. It is not at all like Rachel Weise, Kate Winslet, Lily Evangeline or Keira Knightley (I will cry if Keira ever got that role! She would just ruin it for me).

    http://www.cco.caltech.edu/~gatti/gabaldon/excerpts/graphicnovel/gn_excerpt1.html

    Someone suggested Anna Friel and Rose Byrne… I would have to agree. They look a bit like Claire would and are good actors. Although they would have to really do something about the eyes. Claire is supposed to have Amber colour eyes (as you can see in the sketch in the link above).

    As for Brianna I thoroughly agree with the suggestion of Alicia Witt- because she is tall, slender, pretty, redheaded and has an intensity to her that is like Jamie.

    As much as Jason Isaacs is a great actor and looks menacing… and everyone seems to think he should be Jack Randall… I don’t find him the least bit attractive and Claire clearly states that Frank is supposed to be smooth and handsome. Someone like Jonathon Rhys Meyers would be perfect. Plus I think Cillian Murphy looks a lot like him, so we could easily have an Alexander Randall.

    John Grey is supposed to be blonde and look a bit girly… I thought perhaps Tom Welton?? He’s got the snobbiness about him too.

    It’s been fun looking at all the suggestions though. It’s amazing that most of us think alike about who should play Jamie! I desperately hope there is a movie. Even if it disappoints I hope they try. Every time I read a good book I wish that they made it into a movie so that I can visualise it better.

    By: Nicky on February 1, 2009
    at 9:20 pm

  144. It’s GB or nobody.

    By: rose on February 1, 2009
    at 11:28 pm

  145. Undoubtedly, Gerard Butler has the charm, personality and acting ability to pull off playing Jamie and I can understand why he is the fans’ favorite. But as gorgeous as he is, I don’t think that he is physically best suited for that role. So even though he is one of my favorite actors right now, I’ll have to respectfully disagree with the majority.
    And I don’t think I’ve seen it suggested here yet, but instead of playing Jamie, I think GB would be perfect as Dougal Mackenzie! Am I the only one here who thinks this would be a brilliant piece of casting?? Everytime “The Mackenzie” is described in the books, I cannot imagine anybody else but Gerard Butler! What do you think?

    By: nyca on February 2, 2009
    at 12:09 pm

  146. After reading and rereading the novels, I think Jamie should be an unknown, but wouldn’t it be wonderful if we were given the right to vote?

    By: Bella on February 3, 2009
    at 1:14 pm

  147. Gerard Butler and Kate Winslett. Perfection!! Both could pull off the different ages needed for all the books. Makeup artists are miracle workers. And I agree with the idea of an HBO series, in order to do all of the books justice. Otherwise, it would take years to do it with movies, although it would look great on the big screen.

    By: Moonfairy on February 6, 2009
    at 3:27 am

  148. There were already suggestions about Gerard Butler playing Dougal. Kate Winslet? No, much as I love her, I don’t see her in that role. I have read these books three times over and always picture Gerard in my head as Jamie. They could easily do the younger version via technology. Look at what they did with Kate Blanchett in Benjamin Button? I’ll be happy to see this movie no matter who plays it, but it will always be Gerard’s eyes I picture looking at her and whose voice I picture when I read the books.

    By: Bernadette on February 10, 2009
    at 8:33 am

  149. What about Damian Lewis? He’s a natural redhead, 6′1″, and a good age to play Jamie. Here’s his IMDB page:

    http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0507073/

    By: Erin on February 12, 2009
    at 6:19 am

  150. what about Phillip Winchester? He’s the guy on Crusoe. Has the jaw and knifeblade nose, cat eyes and lovely shoulders.

    By: abigail on February 17, 2009
    at 7:05 pm

  151. Philip Winchester does have a great face for Jaime! And he’s blonde, so it wouldn’t be too hard to make him into a believable redhead since he has the light eyebrows and all. And he’s tall, so that’s good!

    By: Erin on February 18, 2009
    at 4:52 am

  152. I’m afraid I’ve lost enthusiasm for the movie. They can’t put it all into a two-hour film. What story will they zone into? For me, Gerry Butler is Jamie. Granted, he can’t play the 23 year old virgin. That would have been possible, however, for GB a few years ago. So, if they don’t take the majority of the story from the later perspective, I don’t really want to see it on film. I’ll just keep and enjoy my ideas about Jamie in my imagination and the books. No need at all to enhance it with a visual that would only upset and annoy me.

    By: rose on February 27, 2009
    at 9:33 pm

  153. I agree that Kate Winslet would make a perfect Claire. I also thought that Ray Stevenson, Titus Pulio of the Rome Series, would make a fabulous older Jamie. He is tall, good looking and very imposing looking. But I do agree that Gerard Butler is also a great choice. I think it would be best to do this as an HBO series. I don’t think anyone else could do it better.

    By: Kathy on March 5, 2009
    at 12:29 pm

  154. Herself has said that the model Gabriel Aubrey is what Jamie looks like – and he is quite tasty, but unfortunately, not an actor. For me, since I started reading the series in 1992, Claire has always been a young Emma Thompson, pretty but no-nonsense. Now that Emma is regrettably too old, I’ve switched to Keri Russell.

    By: Pamela on March 14, 2009
    at 9:33 am

  155. Michael Cassidy from The O.C. and Smallville might make an excellent Jamie Fraser. He’s only 6 feet tall and American, but has many other similarities to the handsome highlander. He’s the right age, has the look, and is a good actor.

    Clive Owen would make an excellent Dougal or Collum McKenzie. Kate Winslet would be a great Claire-she is who I envision when reading the novels. Just say no to Keira Knightley!

    By: Shannon on March 14, 2009
    at 8:01 pm

  156. I always imagine Gerard Butler when reading Outlander but I like a lot of people have my doubts as to whether he could manage to look 23 and virginal to boot.

    Facially I think Gabriel Aubrey is perfect but he does seem a bit on the skinny side. Not to mention the fact that he isn’t an actor.

    I have a squidoo lens at
    http://www.squidoo.com/Diana-Gabaldon-s-Outlander

    Give your opinion as the whom you think is the best choice.

    By: baboomum on March 15, 2009
    at 3:39 pm

  157. Well, hell, we can’t expect perfection can we? I have to go with Gerald Butler, cause his nose is straight enuf, his forehead is high enuf and his mouth is wide enuf. Plus he’s got the body and has proved he can be imposing in fight scenes. Don’t forget, apart from his tenderness, Jamie is one of the most fierce and ruthless of men too. Whoever played him would HAVE to be convincingly daunting, to merely give a look and turn his enemies to stone!
    As to the Black Jack Randall scene, well, in the book we don’t directly ’see’ what happens, we find out later, when jamie tells claire, so i don’t think there’s a problem with portraying the scene. There’s some things we sure as hell don’t need to see!

    By: lili jazz on March 23, 2009
    at 10:49 pm

  158. I agree it should be someone relatively uknown but gabriel aubrey is closest jamie for me, very chiseled looks. kate beckinsale is definately strong enough to play clare, and she has the classical english look that clare has. it is a pity gabriel aubrey doesn’t act.

    By: dawn on March 26, 2009
    at 5:29 am

  159. Alexander Skarsgard for Jamie all the way. He’s nordic. He’s 6′4″-huge like Jamie, and positively gorgeous! He could certainly pull it off. He doesn’t look his age of 32 in the least. Check out his facial structure, the nose is long, mouth wide, eyes slant upward. What more can I say?

    By: maurine on March 26, 2009
    at 5:42 pm

  160. i would love you to meet my son….who is scot…english and a bit hungarian…..hes 6′4 3/4″ tall….red/blonde hair…and a professional mma fighter….so yes they are out there..(b t w he was called jamie till he was 7)

    By: heather on March 27, 2009
    at 2:53 pm

  161. Will this movie ever come through?????
    Everybody we suggested will probably be old and grey. My vote is still Alex O”Loughlin as Jamie and save him from “three rivers”!!!

    By: Gerda on March 28, 2009
    at 5:18 am

  162. Robert Pattinson

    By: another outlander fan..... on April 2, 2009
    at 6:20 pm

  163. yes, when is a movie or series ever gonna come out?

    By: Suzi on April 3, 2009
    at 6:57 pm

  164. MICHAEL FASSBENDER is the perrrrrfeeeecccttt jamie
    just saw him in hunger 1) he is an amazing actor, his monologue moved me to tears 2) german born with reddish hair so he has the very viking features 3) only 32 4) raised in ireland and in hunger he had the belfast accent which is an interesting mixture of irish, scottish, and english dialect so i am sure he could pick up the highland accent.
    I am reading the books now, currently on drums, and have always pictured gerry but seeing fassbender has completely changed my vision of jamie!

    By: Molly on April 12, 2009
    at 8:14 pm

  165. Kevin McKidd should be Jamie!!!!

    By: Dee on April 15, 2009
    at 3:56 pm

  166. My husband has just the copper/auburn/cinnamon hair Diana describes jamie as having, and the other day, as he was driving I was admiring the copper glint of the hair on his arms, struck by the sun. Claire often mentions jamie’s ‘pelt’ and the sun on his body hair in all those nude haystack/meadow scenes… So, I got to thinking, I love Gerard Butler, and hair can be dyed, but can body hair? I don’t think so, so I think Jamie would have to be played by a real redhead. My hubby also pointed out that no redhead would have the skin tone that Gerard has, he’s too olive. Jamie needs to be ruddy.

    By: lili jazz on April 20, 2009
    at 6:03 pm

  167. This would be a fabulous series for HBO. It simply is too complex a story to be told in a 2 2/5 hr movie. Jamie and Claire’s relationship, adventures, places and key people (ie Bree-Roger) in their lives must be captured so one knows the story from beginning to end.
    As far as casting roles, I’m hoping that common sense prevail — there must be a Jamie, Claire and cast somewhere in the UK – no AMERICAN actors please! That would absolutely be horrible! There are gorgeous, talented actors all over England, Scotland, Irelard. Gerard Butler is good but doesn’t quite fit the age where we first are introduced to Jamie. Just to name a few for characters in the story, Hugh Dancy, Kevin McKidd, Richard Armitage, Rupert Perry Jones, Simon Woods, Sean Bean, Damien Lewis…

    By: Deborah on April 26, 2009
    at 3:35 pm

  168. Everybody and anybody in the least interested in who should play Jamie Fraser in the Outlander movie/series should check out Rupert Friend. He is tall, handsome, sensitive and could play the young, virginal Jamie with no problem whatsoever. Check him out in Mrs Palfrey at the Claremont! He is currently filming “Cheri”.

    By: Gabrielle on May 4, 2009
    at 9:04 pm

  169. philip winchester of the now off-the-air “crusoe” would be one of my choices (although gerald butler is definitely is up there). he’s young enough with potential for on screen aging. jason issacs is a total yes for randall. now let’s get this thing made!!! plus a mini series (like “the tudors”) would be the way to go. too much happens for just a 2 hour movie. besides, a 2 hour movie would not be enough JAMIE FRASER if the casting is perfect!!

    By: diana on May 4, 2009
    at 11:25 pm

  170. Please! Enough talk! This is torture! Half the world has read the series. Somebody make the movie! So far, Gerard Butler seems the best bet for Jamie but only with the right lighting. Moviecraft can make him taller ( Re: Mel Gibson in Braveheart) Please no anorexics for Claire, Tim Roth would be great as Black Jack. Come on, folks, let’s get ‘er done!! Never has there been such a ready made audience!

    By: Diane Piper on May 6, 2009
    at 8:24 am

  171. I think Henry Cavill would make an excellent Jamie. He is a 26 yr old British actor who is 6′ tall. He’s on the Showtime series called The Tudors and you can a check out what he looks like with long hair in Tristan and Isolde. I like Kate Beckinsale for the role of Claire even though I saw Keri Russel in my head as I read the book. I can’t hear Keri doing an English accent though. James McAvoy has Roger written all over him. Judd Law could play Frank/Jack Randall and Nicole Kidman would make an awesome Geilie.

    By: Laura on May 11, 2009
    at 8:44 pm

  172. I agree with Laura, Henry Cavill is young, handsome and strong! Gerard Butler is great but to old.

    By: ando on May 13, 2009
    at 10:14 am

  173. Gerard Butler is an amazing actor and, as Diana Gabaldon said, a great specimen of Scottish manhood, but he just doesn’t match the way that James Fraser is described in the books in the slightest. After watching Rome, I think that Kevin McKidd would make an amazing Jamie: he has the height, the build, the facial features, and he has proven that he knows how to handle a sword. People definitely looked older than they did centuries ago because of the physical demands that were placed on them. Just please, no Robert Pattinson. Yes, he does have the ability to make women swoon, but he just doesn’t have that rugged quality that Jamie has.

    By: emma on May 14, 2009
    at 4:00 pm

  174. Sorry, Gerard Butler is the only one I can see in this role. He has the rugged Scot look for me, the other actors mentioned just don’t look masculine enough for the role, but why ruin a good book with a movie anyway?

    By: piper on May 15, 2009
    at 2:50 pm

  175. We all obviously have our own opions as to what actor should have the honor to play one of the biggest heart throbs in the last century. Gerald Butler, amazing presence with an adorable accent, but alas no Jamie. He’s too old and too dark. Henry Cavill is handsome yes, bu also too dark. There’s nothing worse than trying to make a dark haired man into a redhead. Kevin McKidd isn’t bad but is lacking that certain something that Jamie has. It’s a tough decision. I don’t know that Jamie exists other than in the pages of the Outlander series.

    By: Rosalie on May 16, 2009
    at 11:08 am

  176. While reading the Outlander series I think each one of us has gotten a mental picture of what Jamie should look like. I’m sure that no matter who is chosen to portray him there are going to be some disappointed fans out there. I personally would LOVE to see Gerard Butler as James Fraser. Even though he doesn’t fit the description that everyone seems so key to stay with, I think he does have the sex appeal that is definitely going to be needed to fill this role. Think ahead to the love scenes between Jamie and Claire….. Not only were they steamy, but they were funny. Gerard fits the bill better than anyone out there!(P.S. I Love You?)

    By: Darcee on May 16, 2009
    at 5:05 pm

  177. As an aside don’t you think Rachelle Lefevre (Victoria from Twilight) would make an excellent Brianna? As soon as I saw her I thought of Bree.

    For a chance to vote of your favourite Jamie go to:

    http://www.squidoo.com/Diana-Gabaldon-s-Outlander

    By: mrscookie on May 19, 2009
    at 6:37 am

  178. Paul Bettany is exactly how I pictured Jamie.

    By: Elyria11 on May 20, 2009
    at 3:28 am

  179. I just started reading the Outlander series a few months past and the whole time I have been reading, I have been picturing Gerard Butler as Jamie! He is prefect I think for Jamie Fraser!

    By: ewertz on May 26, 2009
    at 7:44 pm

  180. I have had Cross Stitch for years, and only just read it!
    As soon as I read Jamie s character – I could only see Gerard Butler in the role. I had no idea that a movie was already being planned, and could only think how the book could be transferred to the screen without losing any of its terrifyingly, heart-pounding flavour. Claire is another matter, altogether, and will probably require an a male opinion, to get it right (no offence meant) Jonathan Rhys Meyers is perfect as the Randall men.

    By: Tasha on May 30, 2009
    at 2:52 am

  181. For the longest time, I’ve always been one of those people who was a strong supporter of Gerard Butler as James Fraser, but lately I’ve come to see that Kevin McKidd would make a far greater choice. He could play Jamie from his twenties all the way up through An Echo in the Bone (depending on what happens to James in that novel of course along with the proper make-up). People aged much younger back then, so even though Kevin is much older than twenty two/twenty three years old, he could certainly pull off the part well. When reading the novels and then looking at Kevin on screen, the similarities are uncanny: both Jamie and Kevin are Scottish, both are above six feet tall, both are left handed, and from watching Kevin as Lucius Vorenus in Rome there can be no doubt in anybody’s mind that he could handle the fight scenes incredibly well. Kevin also has very strong Norse features which James is described as having. Yes, I do think that Gerard Butler is an amazing actor who just oozes sexuality, but I’ve always pictured James as more of the stand-up kind of man with a more subdued sexuality about him.

    By: alex on May 30, 2009
    at 5:47 pm

  182. Nikolaj Coster-Waldau, check him out. Just hope he can master the accent and language.

    By: Tasha on June 1, 2009
    at 3:56 am

  183. Jamie Fraser is Gerard Butler, and if you wait any longer we are all going to be dead. I have been following this for ever, what are you waiting for. Jamie and Clair should be the most beautiful people their is. Their are alot of great actors out their and actresses that are great and would love to be in this movie. I love the books of the Outlander and waiting for the next one. I just hope I live longenough to see it complete.

    By: mjrid on June 8, 2009
    at 6:43 am

  184. I am not feelen’ Gerard Butler as Jamie. I’m with you. He is just not what my mind has made. Perhaps it’s because he is needing the red. Red hair is essential. Not only that but Gerard’s face just doesn’t seem to match for some reason.
    My thought is go to Scotland and look for an unknown who fits the bill.
    Just a thought.

    By: Peeps on June 12, 2009
    at 9:12 am

  185. Jamie must be Alexander Skarsgard – he has the height – the talent and the looks – he has been Jamie in my mind for all the books -

    By: Connie Sutherland on June 14, 2009
    at 3:23 pm

  186. I agree with Connie. Alexander Skarsgard is the perfect Jamie. He’s a hot commodity right now with True Blood series. It wouldn’t take much work to change his now blond locks to auburn. His eyes tilt up at the corners like our red haired laddie, and he has a deep sensual voice that will draw female viewers in-if he can pull of the accent! Please get on the Alexander bandwagon.

    By: Innes on June 15, 2009
    at 6:40 pm

  187. Not American actorssssss
    Nooooooo!

    Go to Scotland and find a Scot to play him

    By: Jorden on June 18, 2009
    at 12:34 am

  188. SAM WORTHINGTON!!! He would certainly live up to the handsome rugged Jamie Fraser ;)

    By: Sheye on June 19, 2009
    at 6:07 pm

  189. Oh yes! For sure! Sam Worthington (the new terminator guy) is fine! He’s definitely tall enough (6′2), and he looks really rugged and tough in the movie called Clash of the Titans coming out in 2010.

    By: Dean on June 19, 2009
    at 6:51 pm

  190. Gabriel Aubrey

    By: S on June 21, 2009
    at 12:15 pm

  191. I checked out Sam Worthington on Terminator…”TO
    DIE FOR PERFECT to act as Jamie Fraser!!!! What
    a great Austrialian accent, easily could be the good looking rough Scottish man in his mid-twenties. Evangeline Lilly from Lost would be a perfect match as his 27 yr old Claire!

    By: Sherie on June 22, 2009
    at 4:47 pm

  192. OK… in my mind’s eye I’ve always pictured Gerard Butler as Jamie Fraser when reading the books. None better! Unfortunately I must agree with some of the others, his maturity makes it physically awkward for him to play the young Jamie. Kevin McKidd was wonderful as Lucius Vorenus in HBO’s Rome but frankly as Jamie, he doesn’t quite pull it off for my tastes, plus his jutting brow sort of creeps me out. Ray Stevenson, who played Titus Pullo, could pull it off but he has the same problem as Butler… physically too old. As far as Claire, Keri Russell is spot on!

    I recently saw a movie called “Miss Pettigrew Lives for a Day.” There was a very tall (6’3”), young (3 years younger than Keri Russell), handsome, sexy, romantic and smoldering actor named Lee Pace who played the part of Michael. He reminded me a bit of Clive Owen (who would also be good, but again too old). Henna dye and blue contact lens would cover Jamie’s coloring. Unfortunately for those of you who beg for a Scot in this role, I apologize… he’s American, but according to his IMBD bio, well trained. He pulled of a credible British accent to my American ears, so perhaps he can manage the Scots.

    I haven’t seen Lee Pace in anything else although he has a considerable list of credits. He may be the one with enough obscurity to overcome the issues with readers’ perceptions and preferences while avoiding the pitfalls that comes with a well-known actor.

    By: Mariluz on June 24, 2009
    at 12:40 pm

  193. Gerard Butler looks like a good Jamie.

    By: Kerryn on June 30, 2009
    at 1:56 pm

  194. What about Eva Gaelle Green to play Claire?

    By: Tasha on July 2, 2009
    at 3:09 am

  195. jared padalecki – jamie??

    By: Nicole on July 2, 2009
    at 5:01 pm

  196. I always picture Jamie Fraser played by Kevin McKidd – he plays Dr. Owen Hunt on Grey’s Anatomy.

    Scottish, tall, red headed and gorgeous.
    http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0571727/

    By: Milja on July 3, 2009
    at 11:53 am

  197. I have read the Outlander series more times than I will admit. Can we all agree that the person playing Jamie is going to Have to have a sincere scottish accent or it isn’t going to work at all?! No matter how gorgeous/sexy the actor may be when he opens his mouth to whisper sexy love words to Claire, if it sounds like fake/cheesy Scottish, it just won’t ring true. Thoughts?

    By: Shelly on July 3, 2009
    at 11:58 pm

  198. What about Rachel McAdams for Claire?

    By: Kate on July 5, 2009
    at 6:37 am

  199. I think there are some great ideas, but are they even making an Outlander movie? If anyone knows…please tell me.

    By: Nicole on July 6, 2009
    at 8:57 am

  200. Gerard Butler would be the world’s most perfect Dugal–sorry fans, he’s way too old (as is Ewan MacGregor & Kevin McKidd, sadly…) People, he’s supposed to be 23, not 35-40!!!

    My current #1 pick for Jamie is Robert Buckley, from Lipstick Jungle!! He looks exactly as I have always pictured Jamie: http://www.imdb.com/media/rm4018901504/nm2159347. I LOVE the idea of Henry Cavill too!! If movie magic could make him a redhead, then my number 3 pick would be Jake Gyllenhaal, though at 6′ he might be a bit on the short side for Jamie ::

    Here are my other casting thoughts:

    Jamie (runners up:)): Channing Tatum, Chris Pine, Cam Gigandet

    Claire: Anne Hathaway, Natalie Portman, Rachel McAdams (no stranger to being a time-traveling Claire), Evangeline Lilly, Rachel Weitz, Kate Beckinsale, Marion Cotillard (though the last 3 look a teensy bit older than 27)

    Just my thoughts :)

    By: Leslie on July 6, 2009
    at 4:35 pm

  201. My number one pick for Jamie is Eric Bana…he could play young and older Jamie well.

    By: maura on July 9, 2009
    at 9:32 am

  202. YOu are SO right…The only way the whole story can be told, with out leaving anything out and to do justise to the complex charactoer Diana has ceated would be to do an HBO mini series..I think it would rival the Tudors!
    As for who would play Jamie..It IS a difficult quest…one that equals the search for Scarlett O’Hara.

    By: Melissa on July 15, 2009
    at 6:15 pm

  203. I think Gerard Butler is amazingly good-looking, but is WAY too old to play Jamie, who is in his early twenties! my pick would have to be Simon Woods, who played Mr. Bingley. He has boyish good-looks, but has that presence that Jamie needs. He has the red hair as well. The more important question would be the actress to play Claire Randall. The character calls for a woman in her mid-twenties who has strength and maturity. That is going to be that hardest part to cast.

    By: Megan on July 16, 2009
    at 10:09 am

  204. I think Brianna could be played by the singer Joss Stone, and I agree about Simon Woods playing a young Jamie Fraser. He would need to bulk up a bit for the mature Jamie role, however. As far as Claire, I think Ruth Wilson would be a great pick.

    By: S. G. on July 16, 2009
    at 10:49 pm

  205. Can some please tell me how Gerard Butler is supposed to pull off a 22 year old virgin with red hair that is close to 6′4 in the first book Outlander?

    I am so glad you all arent the casting directors

    By: Becca on July 18, 2009
    at 7:38 am

  206. Yes I agree. Gerard Butler is way too old, but he could still play someone in Outlander. I agree with having Sam Worthington as Jamie.

    By: Nicole on July 18, 2009
    at 5:33 pm

  207. What about Rupert Grint? He’s very young but perhaps by the time the movie comes out he will have grown up a bit?

    By: Tina on July 26, 2009
    at 10:22 am

  208. I think Robert Pattinson could make a good Jamie, if he could pull off the Scottish accent and gain some muscle.

    By: Mercedes on July 28, 2009
    at 4:53 pm

  209. I think Jamie Fraser should be Gerard Butler and Claire should be either Kate Beckinsale or Rachel Weisz… Rachel Weisz could play Claire’s attitude really well. This would give the movie the humor it deserves … These are wonderful books… I sure hope they do something with them.

    By: Donna on July 29, 2009
    at 1:27 pm

  210. and yes… they can make Gerard look just as young as he needs to be. HBO series wouldn’t bother me either. It has to be Gerard and Kate Beckinsale or Rachel Weisz… this would just make the movie/show for me.

    By: Donna on July 29, 2009
    at 2:25 pm

  211. i really don’t want to see these books subject to the so-called script writters of the big screen. i saw and hated what they did to the ” Lord of The Rings” only if Diana Gabaldon herself did the script Would i ever cosider going to see it!!!!!!!!!!

    By: karleen on August 2, 2009
    at 8:49 pm

  212. I totally agree with Leslie:

    “My current #1 pick for Jamie is Robert Buckley, from Lipstick Jungle!! He looks exactly as I have always pictured Jamie: http://www.imdb.com/media/rm4018901504/nm2159347.“

    By: G&EMommy on August 3, 2009
    at 12:01 am

  213. ANDY MURRAY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    http://bettorsedge.files.wordpress.com/2009/07/andy-murray1.jpg

    By: Bea on August 6, 2009
    at 8:51 am

  214. Michael Weaver…

    By: Jessie on August 7, 2009
    at 11:55 am

  215. I agree, as a HUGE Gerard Butler fan, that he is not the right one to play Jamie. I also think that folks have to keep in mind that Jamie is 24 in the novel Outlander, whoever plays him in said movie would have to be a younger man than Kevin McKidd or Gerard Butler…

    By: whereigoreviews on August 10, 2009
    at 4:07 am

  216. I have to agree with you, there is nothing wrong with Gerry, he’s goodlooking guy etc. BUT he is not Jamie. Never.
    Sean Bean would truly be better Jamie
    See here why
    http://media.photobucket.com/image/Sean%20Bean%20as%20boromir/ckstroud/BD_hq.jpg
    JAmie is only young in first movie, in the others he will be older, like age of Sean Bean

    By: Sanna on August 17, 2009
    at 7:39 am

  217. Sam Worthington for Jamie and Rachel McAdams for Claire.

    By: Alexia on August 19, 2009
    at 5:49 pm

  218. Garrett Hedlund for Jamie Fraser !

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8YFkc3z1Nq8

    The eyes, the hair, the general sexiness…

    By: Audree on August 25, 2009
    at 7:52 pm

  219. Alexander Skarsgard .. perfect for jamie .. and I believe he could pull off the red hair .. be it a little darker .. he has the height and build .. eyes .. and looks .. and he can do accents .. oh and he can act as well ..

    By: Jenni on August 26, 2009
    at 3:26 pm

  220. Butler isn’t doing HBO anytime soon. The matter-of- fact attitude James Fraser has? Gerard Butler is perfect for the job.

    By: Robert on August 27, 2009
    at 12:47 am

  221. Mmm, a lot of new (to me) names for Jamie.
    I like Butler, but he is far to old (as a lot of other suggestions are as well).

    Just for the picture (because I don’t think this formule1 coureur can act): google ‘Jenson Button’

    Can’t you make a page where all the pictures can be seen?

    By: outlanderfan on August 27, 2009
    at 7:22 am

  222. I am very behind the times on this posting but I would like to say something. I personally, think it would a very bad idea for Outlander to be a HBO series. Mainly because there ARE people like myself that are very avid Outlander fans that do not have cable or if they do have cable they only have basic cable. There ARE people out there that love the series that simply can not afford those types of luxuries as cable or digital cable and therefore it would not be fair to those fans to not be able to see it. I don’t think that would be a very good decision on Diana’s part to do something like that. She has too many fans in all classes. And I’m sure quite a few in the lower middle class or even lower class income bracket that have found the books BECAUSE of a lack of money situation putting their main entertainment venue as reading.

    By: Dawn on September 7, 2009
    at 3:19 am

  223. I think that Jaimie should be Kevin McKidd. He has the look. And as far as age, people looked older than they were back then. They showed age faster due to how hard life was. PLUS look at his background before he met Claire, he already had a hard life so he would look older than age might seem. He just needs longer hair.
    http://www.ojotele.com/images/2008/11/kevin_mckidd.jpg

    And after looking at the picture Diana posted as being Claire, I think Rachel Weiss would be perfect for her.

    Rachel:
    http://www.lahiguera.net/cinemania/actores/rachel_weisz/fotos/1895/rachel_weisz.jpg

    Claire drawing from Diana’s site:
    http://www.cco.caltech.edu/~gatti/gabaldon/new_images/claire_color.jpg

    And another note on age in movies: Just remember what they can do with makeup these days. Most of the characters are going to be several ages throughout the story so no matter who gets picked, they will have to be made up for several different ages.

    By: Dawn on September 7, 2009
    at 3:33 am

  224. AXL ROSE!!! LOL

    By: lili jazz on September 9, 2009
    at 6:58 pm

  225. Robert Buckley should play Jamie! He often has red in his hair as well!!

    By: christina on September 10, 2009
    at 10:36 am

  226. What about Alexander Skarsgard? He’s swedish, not scottish, but he has the whole viking look natrually. Just die his hair red and away you go. He’s 6′4″, broad shoulder and straight nose… the whole 9 yards. All he needs now is to learn a little Gaelic and he’d be great.

    By: MC on September 18, 2009
    at 11:06 am

  227. Gerard Butler’s too OLD… At least for Outlander.

    By: Marie on September 18, 2009
    at 11:20 am

  228. i have read and loved all the books and counting down the days left to an echo in the bone. as far as casting for outlander goes i have seen alot of jamies and other characters and i have to say it ended in me shouting at the computer about some choices.diana gabaldon has on her website who she thinks and her thoughts on who should play what part and i have to say the woman got it spot on and who better but the woman herself to put forward her thought. and may i say her jamie is fab and is exactly how he should be seen.(yummy) OMG…. i just feel everyone needs to not be making the film about big popular actors.i think it might take away from the film and the story and then we will all be very upset if it’s not done as we all know it should be….

    By: karin on September 21, 2009
    at 2:31 am

  229. i have read and loved all the books and counting down the days left to an echo in the bone. as far as casting for outlander goes i have seen alot of jamies and other characters and i have to say it ended in me shouting at the computer about some choices.diana gabaldon has on her website who she thinks and her thoughts on who should play what part and i have to say the woman got it spot on and who better but the woman herself to put forward her thought. and may i say her jamie is fab and is exactly how he should be seen.(yummy) OMG…. i just feel everyone needs to not be making the film about big popular actors.i think it might take away from the film and the story and then we will all be very upset if it’s not done as we all know it should be….sam worthington????? REALLY!!!!!!come on people jamie is supposed to have a good jaw bone, straight nose think of vikings people…get past who you think is hot and think about the acting aspect.. bring in an unknown. look at rob pattison we all love edward!! unknown is not bad…….

    By: karin on September 21, 2009
    at 2:37 am

  230. I’m only crossing my fingers for one thing: Just please PLEASE do not make Jamie Fraser look like Richie Cunningham or sound like an American.

    By: Paula Divello on September 21, 2009
    at 1:52 pm

  231. Ok… part 2 – changed my mind, I think Michael Fassbender is Jamie. (really, I think Jamie is every woman’s fantasy guy, that’s why he can’t be decided by everyone…) He’s Irish, not a Scot, but he just has a Jamie presence to me. Most recently in Inglorious Basterds, was in 300 too. What d’ya THINK?

    http://www.smh.com.au/ffximage/2008/11/07/warriormain_wideweb__470×315,0.jpg

    http://z.about.com/d/movies/1/0/R/p/N/300pubc.jpg

    http://www.filmdope.com/Gallery/ActorsF/46535-27476.gif

    By: Paula Divello on September 22, 2009
    at 9:44 am

  232. Jamie is sooo important to cast – Jamie & Claire are so vital and I don’t think any of the choices so far….are going to work.. Crossing my fingers they work as hard on casting this as Twilight, or they will ruin this magnificient man. The guy needs to have presence and size – I almost think Rob Pattinson because he has the charisma and seems to be able to adopt accents easily….and is 6′1″. So many actors are so short! Jamie needs to have sparkle and Claire…. let’s just say I would love, love to be on casting these people. There is no room for error.

    By: carolyn on September 23, 2009
    at 10:25 am

  233. I think of someone like Jason Lewis as Jamie Fraser. Attractive beyond words, quite, humble, strong, passionate. Gerrad Butler does not remind me of Jamie Fraser at all. I agree hopefully HBO will take it up as a serious. That would be FANTASTIC!

    By: Jessica on September 27, 2009
    at 9:45 pm

  234. I have to say, I have seen a real Jamie Fraser in real life, with Claire’s amber colored eyes though, not blue. And it was a humbling experience; especially since he was married to my sister-in-law. But, he doesn’t act, so we are back to square one. I think Gerry doesn’t look Nordic enough, but he is the best I have been able to think of so far. There HAS to be a newcomer out there who would be perfect.

    By: Amy on September 28, 2009
    at 1:19 pm

  235. CHRIS HEMSWORTH 6′3″ would be the PERFECT Jamie. He’s young, tall, muscular, and sexy. He even has catlike eyes and since he has light hair he would look great with the red hair. I also feel that KERI RUSSELL could play the role of Clair and do that role justice. She has an angelic face of someone who would be from the 40’s. She’s an amazing actress and she also has crazy curly hair with the perfect coloring too.

    People need to stop saying that all these older actors and actresses can play the roles. Jamie is a young 24 year old not a 40 something man. Clair is only 28 not 40 either. Though a lot of the older actors would have done a wonderful job 10 years ago, they are too old for the role now.

    By: Dawn on September 29, 2009
    at 7:29 am

  236. Kellan Lutz would be a great youg Jamie. I can picture him as a 22-year old virgin! I also think he could grow into Gerrard Bulter. Kellan is American, but his face could be Scottish and his body could be Jamie’s! Check him out!

    By: Ali on September 29, 2009
    at 8:48 am

  237. Oh my goodness, I just saw a pic of CHRIS HEMSWORTH and I totally believe that this guy can be jamie. He screams jamie and most important he is age appropiate. We need to stop focusing on these older men to play jamie. If they are going to make the movie its to focus on the first book when he was in his 20’s.

    By: yrma on September 29, 2009
    at 10:05 am

  238. Here is my cast:
    James Fraser – Gerard Butler (with reddish hair) or Karl Urban (just slap some blue eyes on him and he’ll be good to go) or even Hugh Jackman (put red hair on him and wa lah see this picture of him http://www.google.com/imgres?imgurl=http://www.webwombat.com.au/lifestyle/fashion_beauty/images/jackman-1.jpg&imgrefurl=http://www.webwombat.com.au/lifestyle/fashion_beauty/jackman.htm&usg=__L_BJmcXzFQ0GVfHJullh9M9jK6o=&h=325&w=300&sz=27&hl=en&start=7&sig2=xId4GhfTGwYXaQCWTXqILg&tbnid=y_ZRLeMPaSER9M:&tbnh=118&tbnw=109&prev=/images%3Fq%3DHugh%2Bjackman%26hl%3Den&ei=M8rhSofdB4-qlAe7r52KBw) Alex O’Lougling also looks good I just haven’t seen him around and CHRIS HEMSWORTH is a very good choice too (if not for jamies son too)

    Claire – Rachel Weiss (i think she is a dead ringer for claire with yellow eyes and all and also feisty)

    Jack Randall – Love Jason Isaacs for this one he can be perfectly mean.

    Ian – Hugh Dancy

    William – Jamies son think Robert Pattison… would definitely fit the bill

    Bree – lisa sheldon is a good choice but is she tall?

    Roger MacKenzie- Look at Matthew Bomer he is just getting popular with a new tv series… cute!

    Jamie’s sister – Kate Blanchette… would be great but too big an actress to play that role… maybe Sarah McLeod

    I am so happy they are doing a version of this books. I fell in love with my imaginary Jamie Fraser and from seeing a lot of movies with Gerard Butler I do think he is my first choice. He can be gentle and funny (see PS I love you) unbelievable fighting skills and the body oh-my-god (see 300 for that one) AAAAAND he’s got the Scottish accent to boot. First choice hands down… as far as playing young jamie.. they can fix things for that… look at the curious case of benjamin button… they made brad look like a kid with CGI and was AWESOME.

    I hope they do make it into a loong series only to make the books justice. It is such a good story line!!

    By: Michelle on October 23, 2009
    at 8:10 am

  239. Why not Kevin McKidd from Made of Honor. He played a Scottish Duke. Wonderful. All I could see was Jamie when I saw him.

    By: k on October 23, 2009
    at 2:11 pm

  240. Wow, this thread just keeps on going. I just read Outlander for the first time a week ago, but felt the need to chime in as a new fan! :)

    Claire: Rachel Weisz would make a phenomenal Claire. Can’t think of anyone better suited at the moment.

    Jamie: So difficult to assign any actor to Jamie because he is just too perfect – but I think Chase Crawford would do the part well. A bulkier Chase would steam up the screen, and I think he’s around 6′. Someone mentioned Chris Hemsworth – I agree 100%! Either of these two guys would fit the rather large bill, IMO. I’m trying to envision someone who could pull off red hair like Jamie and that’s difficult to do. Definitely needs to be a gloriously well-built, tall man, w/ blue eyes, who can wear a short beard and also longer locks. Also, I picture Jamie as young and buff. Not an easy choice.

    Black Jack/Randall: I like Isaacs for the part as well. Someone on another site mentioned Rufus Sewell – another great choice, but the actor will need to slightly resemble Frank, so that would be a tough one.

    Dougal: I like the idea of Gerard Butler, or Eric Bana. Needs to be slightly older but great looking per DG’s description. I can’t envision Butler as Jamie in any way. He’s just not hunky enough for me and w/ red hair? Just not seeing it. Butler as Dougal – YES!

    Bree: I envision Emmy Rossum but I’m not sure if the height would be an issue.

    Roger: Tom Welling, hands down. A tall, slender guy who could pull off dark hair and green eyes with ease, as well as carry a scholarly appeal.

    I haven’t given the others much thought. :) I hope a movie, or series of movies, emerge. Someone also mentioned the possibility of HBO taking the reigns – so long as they stick to the actual books rather than write new material or take it too far off-track, this would be a great option. I, personally, think HBO butchered Charlaine Harris’ Sookie Stackhouse series – but I still tune in. :)

    By: cheerio on October 27, 2009
    at 4:40 pm

  241. Unfortunately the beautiful Gerard Butler is too old to play Jamie. But check out PAUL TELFER on Goggle images. He is Scots and absolutely gorgeous. He is my vote to play Jamie (with a little hair dye of course!).

    By: Becca on October 30, 2009
    at 7:21 am

  242. As one of the many lovers of Jamie Fraser, and someone who would love to see him on the screen, I’m afraid whoever plays his part, will be a disappointment. We have imagined and fantasized for years what he looks like in our minds and no man will ever fill his boots or kilt, but it will be exciting when it finally comes about.

    By: Suzy on October 31, 2009
    at 7:11 am

  243. It hit me this afternoon while I was reading in my car and listening to Pearl Jam….Eddie Vedder in his younger years (and with red hair) would have been the perfect Jamie!

    By: Maggie on November 5, 2009
    at 7:51 pm

  244. I can’t imagine any actor playing the part of Jamie Fraser. We who have read about and imagined what Jamie looks like will no doubt be disappointed with who ever plays the braw Scotsman. Of course we fans do want to see the film happen in our lifetime, it is an amazing tale we will all remember.

    By: Suzy on November 6, 2009
    at 4:52 pm

  245. I like Butler and I also think Liam Neeson would be perfect if you could make him younger for the early work. I also think Kevin McKidd would be a good choice.

    By: mary on November 8, 2009
    at 6:30 pm

  246. Tony Curran. Please.

    By: Hannah on November 13, 2009
    at 3:53 pm

  247. I don’t know who could do Jamie justice, but I have a great choice for Briana, Paige Stark. She’s tall, young enough , perfect hair and coloring and she’s a fine, unknown actor.

    By: nancy on November 13, 2009
    at 7:09 pm

  248. These are my picks:

    Rachel Weisz would do a great job portraying Claire.

    Jamie: David Wenham.

    Black Jack/Randall: Ian Gruffund, slender/slight, effeminate but this guy could probably play old Ian as well.

    Jenny: Naomi Watts, she’d be pretty/small & feisty.

    Dougal: Gerard Butler because he’d make a good warrior, rough, harsh, and twisted enough.

    Colum: Tony Curran, most definitely.

    Bree: Laura Preppon, she’s tall, redheaded and Bree’s supposed to have the American thing going on. She’s definitely my vision of Jamie & Claire’s child. My 2nd choice is Bryce Dallas Howard because of the red hair & the cat eyes.

    Roger: Jim Sturgess. I also picture my Roger as tall/slender but still rough. All he needs is contact lenses and a good voice.

    Geillie: Michelle Forbes made such a crazy Maryann in True Blood, she’d fit right in as Geillie Duncan.

    Laoghaire: Juno Temple as the young version & Anna Maxwell Martin as the older version.

    I really can’t think of anyone fitting young Ian’s shoes and I could probably dwell on this for a while. All in all to say, it’s ok if the actors are a bit older because back in the days & 300yrs ago they ALL looked older due to food & living conditions so that’s fine. I also bet Hollywood could make anyone look younger/older, smaller/bigger, taller/shorter, they can do it all so nay worries there, lol… If we can find actors that are charismatic & charming enough, they can probably be molded to fit everyone’s perception.

    By: Allys on November 21, 2009
    at 7:43 pm

  249. Alexander Skarsgard is Jamie Fraser. 6′4″ amazing body, has that nordic bone structure, slanted cat-like blue eyes, amazing actor, and would probably be able to carry an accent quite well. All that’s needed is some red hair dye and he is perfect!!

    http://www.alexander-skarsgard.de/galerie/displayimage.php?album=toprated&cat=2&pos=8

    http://www.imdb.com/media/rm3959064832/nm0002907

    By: Molly on November 22, 2009
    at 5:21 pm


Leave a response






Your response:

Categories